What HRs Miss When Drafting an Employment Agreement (Without ESOPs)

HR Legal Experts

The fastest way that an organization can run into avoidable legal trouble is not through complex policies; it usually begins with a simple employment agreement that no one reviewed carefully or that was copied from the internet.

This happens most often with an employment agreement which does not have standard ESOP related clauses.

This is because the said document looks routine and feels like basic onboarding paperwork that gets filed away as soon as it is signed. But this simplicity is exactly where major legal issues begin.

At HR Legal Experts, we see this frequently across startups and growing companies in India. HR teams move fast, hiring is urgent, and old templates feel convenient. At that speed, critical clauses that protect the company and reduce future disputes often get overlooked. 

This is why a clear, updated employment agreement (without ESOPs) India is far more important than most organisations realise. When drafted with intention, it prevents misunderstandings, ensures compliance, and strengthens organisational clarity.

HR Mistakes in Employment Agreements

Skipping the basics of compliance

One of the most common mistakes is skipping essential compliance requirements.

Many employment agreements fail to align with basic Indian labour laws. Some do not even contain proper termination clause. Others omit mandatory references to the applicable Shops and Establishments Act, and many still rely on outdated templates that do not reflect changes in notice period rules, working hours, data protection obligations, or employee rights.

A legally sound employment agreement need not be lengthy, but it must be correct and aligned with laws such as:

• the Indian Contract Act, 1872
• the relevant Shops and Establishments Act
• essential clauses on leave, confidentiality, and termination

When these are missing, the agreement may appear complete, but it exposes the organisation to significant legal and operational risks.

Vague job descriptions and deliverables

Another major mistake HR teams make is keeping the job description overly generic.

Using vague lines such as “the employee will perform duties as assigned” may seem flexible but leaves too much room for interpretation.

Without a basic outline of responsibilities, performance discussions become harder, expectations become misaligned, and it becomes difficult to justify performance concerns or take action during appraisals or exits.

A much better approach is to include a brief but clear description of the role’s purpose and key deliverables while still allowing flexibility with a statement that duties may evolve based on business needs. This keeps expectations realistic without restricting the role unnecessarily.

Weak confidentiality and data protection clauses

Confidentiality and data protection clauses are also commonly neglected, even though companies today handle sensitive information such as client data, employee details, financial information, and intellectual property.

Yet many agreements still include only a one-line confidentiality clause that does not reflect modern realities.

Now that the Digital Personal Data Protection Act (DPDP Act), 2023 is in force, generic clauses are not only outdated but also non-compliant. 

A strong confidentiality clause should clearly outline:

• how data may be used
• what cannot be shared
• the employee’s responsibilities under the DPDP Act
• what must happen to confidential information when employment ends

Strengthening this clause alone can protect the organisation from serious legal and financial consequences.

Unclear probation and confirmation terms

Unclear probation and confirmation terms - HR Legal Experts

Probation clauses are another area where agreements frequently fall short.

Many agreements define the probation duration but leave out what happens once the period ends.

This leads to confusion about whether confirmation is automatic, whether an extension is allowed, and what happens if HR forgets to issue a confirmation letter.

This ambiguity creates problems later when calculating notice periods, conducting appraisals, or addressing performance concerns.

A clear probation clause should always specify the duration, the criteria for confirmation, and whether the confirmation is automatic or must be formally documented.

Missing termination clarity

The termination clause is perhaps the most sensitive section of an employment agreement, yet it is often poorly drafted.

A single line stating a one-month notice period is insufficient and does not protect either the organisation or the employee.

A well-drafted termination clause should explain:

• termination for cause
• termination without cause
• garden leave
• notice pay
• circumstances for immediate termination

A detailed clause is not harsh. It is fair and transparent and significantly reduces disputes.

Not aligning with internal policies

Another major oversight occurs when HR teams fail to align the employment agreement with internal company policies.

Many employees later claim they were not aware of or required to follow policies related to POSH, leave, code of conduct, attendance, remote work, or disciplinary procedures simply because the agreement did not reference them.

A simple statement confirming that the employee agrees to comply with all company policies, as amended from time to time, automatically links the agreement with the organisation’s policies and eliminates ambiguity.

For deeper guidance on how leading companies manage compliance consistency, you can read our article on Top 10 Legal Experts in India.

Final Reflection

Employment agreements don’t need to be complicated to be effective.

The most reliable agreements are simple, clear, compliant, and easy for employees to understand.

When companies update their templates, remove outdated language, and ensure clarity, they reduce disputes and build stronger trust with their people.

HR Legal Experts helps organisations draft employment agreements (without ESOPs) that work in real life, not just on paper. Agreements that protect the business, support HR operations, and give employees the clarity they deserve from day one.

If you need help drafting or reviewing your employment agreement, our team is here to make the process easier, compliant, and reliable for you.